Christian Doctrine logo, Home


B

i

b

l

e

 

T

h

e

o

l

o

g

y

 

M

i

n

i

s

t

r

i

e

s

N

E

W

S




Home

About BTM

The Beacon

eBooks

Contact

Make a
Donation

FAQ

Index of
Topics

Muslim Forum

News

Periodicals

Seeking God

Testimonies

Alpharisms

December 2004

By: K. B. Napier

The Alpha course is one of the biggest and latest spiritual confidence tricks in the world and many thousands succumb to its charms every week, all around the world. What makes it a scam? Its self-aggrandisement coupled with its Arminian presentation of the Gospel, and a charismatic source.

You cannot escape the fact that praise is given to Alpha and not to Christ, even within its own promotional literature. For so many weak Christians today the logo and brand of Alpha is greater than the Gospel it purports to preach!

Christ said “If you love me, you will obey my commandments.” His commandments include the proper preaching of His Gospel. The apostle Paul defined this as the Gospel that he and the apostles preached – anything else was to be considered ‘anathema’. There can be no doubt whatever that Alpha does NOT preach this authentic Gospel, but a ‘gospel that is no gospel’. Therefore, it is anathema.

Its leaders and supporters have no excuse. The Gospel is tied inextricably to the truths of predestination and election. Alpha rides roughshod over them, denying them existence. The reason is obvious – if Alpha actually preached the genuine Gospel it would lose almost all of its adherents!

Why? Because those who adhere to it prefer the weak and godless teachings of Arminianism, which give Man the position of mini-gods. To remove its influence would be to remove their own influence! It would also remove their false belief systems.

It is no coincidence that Alpha came from a charismatic cess-pit. Satan wishes to build up a staggeringly vast empire of ‘almost Christians’, whose very presence and work tries to annul the true Gospel. I refer to charismaticism as a cess-pit because that is what it is. Charismaticism is a cess-pit, because it contains huge numbers of heresies and anti-Bible teachings and practices.

I say that leaders of Alpha are useless*, without spiritual discernment. No Godly status can be given to spreaders of spiritual muck! (*In scripture the word ‘useless’ is applied to anything that has no spiritual worth to offer).

It is also no coincidence that Alpha has a strong and growing Roman Catholic contingency, even though Christians throughout the ages have considered Catholicism to be the harlot of scripture. Having studied and taught The Revelation, I can only concur that the description in that book of the harlot really does appear to fit Rome, with its multi-layered strata of evil and error. Roman Catholicism is just as much a cult as Mormonism and JWism. Yet, Holy Trinity, Brompton, the managers and perpetrators of Alpha, could not care less. To them, any untruth is fine and any association is acceptable.

I repeat what I have said in my original assessment of Alpha, that all who teach or lead Alpha are not called by God to do so. I can say this without fear of contradiction, because God does not prompt any Christian to support or preach heresy!

It is also my contention that those who lead Alpha groups do so because of their own immense failure to be obedient servants of the Most High God. They do not obey, they believe heresy, and teach the same. There is no way I can cushion these facts.

(Am I being harsh? I do not think so. I have learned that talking softly in the face of continuous heresy does nothing. I can talk softly to those I meet face-to-face, and whose heart is repentant or at least willing. But hardened hearts require more of a jack-hammer than a weak smile! You will find this to be so in scripture itself).

Only those without a mandate to preach and teach will support and teach Alpha. It gives them some kind of status and meaning in life, because their own lives are woefully lacking in truth and real godly intent. That is, they have no calling from God, so their next best move is to associate with a successful movement. I do not care who this applies to – for it applies to all who lead Alpha.

Alpha pretends to be the catch-all course for everybody! God’s Gospel does not say that it catches-all in its net. God does not throw out an invitation to choose salvation. He chose whoever would be saved even before He made the world!

Logic tells me that if God chose everybody who will ever be saved, before He even made the first man and woman, then it stands to reason that no man or woman can ever choose to be saved.

They cannot alter God’s decision, for those who are saved in time have already been saved in eternity! Give away as many suppers as you wish – they will not make Christians. They will not save. Pray as ‘hard’ as you wish, you will not be saved if you are not elect. Learn an immense background to ‘Christianity’, but it will still leave you at square one, without a Saviour or hope. Election is the key.

But, Alpha arrogantly carries on regardless, preaching a lie and taking the praise for it. And the lie is so huge it drags in big names such as popes, archbishops, pop stars and sportsmen. They are all deluded, every one of them, and none of them have any idea of genuine Biblical theology.

Time and again my critics tell me that Alpha is a genuine tool of the Gospel, so they can tolerate its ‘errors’. This is not God’s way. He tells us that His word is perfect and that He does not cause men to commit or believe error. Rather, when we find error we must oppose it and demand repentance.

In this paper I give just a few brief notes about present Alpha news. I will leave praise for Alpha to all who are deluded and whose theology is dead. Do not speak to me of numbers or of people supposedly being saved ‘by Alpha’, because they are worthless facts based on a lie. If you don’t believe me, look at 2 Thessalonians, where we are told specifically and clearly that God has chosen whom He wishes to save. Deny it at your own peril!

Good News

One local vicar, after reading our material on Alpha, took down his Alpha posters and stopped the course. I thank God for his testimony and courage, especially for a man in a denomination at the forefront of promoting Alpha!

God’s Managers?

Alpha assumes that God is unable to operate without humanly-appointed managers! That is why there is a proliferation of conferences and seminars and centralised control.

It does not matter which sector of society you wish to aim at, Alpha folk have a ready-made answer, which involves leaders attending a conference, to be told how to run the courses.

Compare with the way the churches originally began. It is very clear in scripture that the apostles visited an area and preached. They then taught the new Christians doctrinal truths, which they expected to be obeyed.

After that, Paul and the others continued to visit as they could, and sent letters of advice, rebuke and help. But there were no conferences or seminars! Each local church grew as the Lord wished it to grow. Their growth in spirituality depended on their obedience, not on newly written ideas from a human point of view.

Paul did not establish marriage conferences, as Alpha does. He just taught the whole counsel of God and expected everyone to obey. Today, we are in a far better position for we have the whole counsel of God in writing. The answer to marriage problems is not to attend an Alpha course on marriage, but to read God’s word and obey everything in it.

Then there are the ‘tried and tested ways’ that Christians can copy, to help the poor and the excluded in society…again provided by an Alpha course! Scripture contains the principles for all these things – why go to charismaticised heretics for answers when God has already given them?

Or, what about building thriving and growing churches? Of course – Alpha has the answer! For goodness sake, friends, shake off the lethargy and sin! Turn from the glittering baubles offered by Holy Trinity, and turn back to God. His word has the answers, not Alpha. Stop wasting your time on Alpha and get back to reading God’s word for yourself. Don’t rely on the interpretations of Arminian teachers.

Then there are conferences to help Christians who wish to offer help to ex-offenders. Again, we must go back to scripture, where the principles of help are given. Very often, today, Christians help those in society whom God has Himself rejected.

Christians who help in this way heap coals of God’s anger upon their own heads. I even heard of one pastor who teaches that God wishes to offer love to all who are reprobate, even though scripture says the exact opposite.

It seems that charismatics specialise in helping reprobates, who stand condemned by God for sins which make them utterly wicked. To help men condemned by God is heresy and is itself wicked. Be careful whom you help, friends, for you might otherwise incur God’s wrath.

I have no problem with helping ex-offenders IF they turn from their crimes and repent. If they do not, Christians have no business helping them. Sadly, too many Christians help people who are sinful haters of God.

Our Sad, Theologically-Challenged, Sinful, Archbishop!

Dr Rowan Williams is said to be an academic whiz-kid. Why, then, does he have such sinful theological views? His academic brilliance is not found in his ‘spiritual’ pronouncements – his views on homosexuality are just one example of his ineptidude. Behind it are his theological errors.

Is he truly a born-again person? I cannot tell. Some of his words seem right – but that is easy for anyone who spends his time in an Anglican frock. His views, which are based on his theology, are very unsound, leading many into the jaws of deceit. 

However, his view that Alpha is “an open door” is correct – an open door for cults and the occult to get into the hearts and minds of thousands of people; an opening for so many churchified errors.

The archbishop likened the Christian faith to a landscape, and Alpha as a guide through it. Once again, we have a supposedly Christian leader describe Christianity as something you can simply learn about. The implication is serious – that Alpha (or any other Arminian heresy), by chatting about a variety of things, can somehow produce Christians by ‘guiding’ them through topics of interest.

His argument speaks of people seeing ‘Christians’ acting out their faith ‘seriously’ and so wanting to be like them. In other words, choosing Christ rather than being elected to salvation before time began. Sadly, when he was Bishop of Monmouth, he encouraged all priests in his diocese to attend an Alpha course.

Rev. F.

Rev. F. has a responsible public position. Yet, he supports and promotes Alpha. When a lady questioned him about it, he got on his high horse and told her that he knew his stuff because he was studying for his PhD!! Oh dear, what a childish way to respond! This is the way men typically fob-off genuine critics.

In my own emails to him I spoke of his spiritual paucity – because that is what a person has when he or she supports Alpha, knowing the hard evidence from scripture that denounces it.

His non-responses were typical of those who have no argument, for he did not answer a single objection put to him. Instead, he quoted the thousands who disagreed with me (charismatics and pro-charismatics, of course), and even relies on Yonggi Cho, who most reformed Christians now recognise as a man on the wrong path.

To support this deluded view, Rev F. resorts to an old but well-used charismatic ploy. To quote: “Let us let God be the judge of Alpha and the work of the Holy Spirit in the world.” Oh dear again! God has ALREADY judged Alpha in His word!! Read scripture and you will find evidence against Alpha. No problem.

In my own 34 page original criticism I listed a number of known heresies inherent in Alpha. We already have a  long and growing catalogue of unholy activities found in charismatic circles. So, why do we need to ‘wait’?? What’s extra to scripture?

Like so many, Rev. F. is deluded and cannot discern what is spiritually right or wrong. Instead of arguing his position from scripture, he quotes others and resorts to vagueness. Alpha is already judged and found wanting. Yet, this man, like many others, hangs on to deception. Why? Because he has nothing else in his life, nothing that is genuine.

The Constant Theme

There is nothing wrong with giving an outline of Christianity to anyone. But this goes wrong when those who call themselves Christians think that this in itself can persuade people to become Christians.

Yet, this is a constant theme in Alpha – the course is for those who want to know about Christianity. It is very evident that leaders think this is enough. There is no consciousness of God’s grace and His predestination of souls to salvation!

At a large gathering, where Nicky Gumbel presided, he did his usual interviews. And, guess what? He wanted them to tell everybody how Alpha had changed their lives! Alpha, not Christ. It does not matter if Christ was the second word to pass their lips – Alpha was the first.

One of them said that he now goes to prisons “talking about the Christian faith”. Really, that sums up what is going on. Are these thousands of people who are ‘converted’ only converted to Alpha? Or are they genuine Believers? No genuine speaker will talk about the ‘Christian faith’ – he will talk about Christ!

The ‘faith’ is being sold as a package of goodies – join this movement and you will get lots of friends and benefits, and do something interesting.

This theme is found throughout Alpha News…come to Alpha! Learn about Christianity at Alpha! Not ‘read about God in your Bible’, or ‘listen to genuine preaching and repent’!

BBC Report

Bearing in mind that the BBC is no more ‘Christian’ biased than your average porn king, Alpha was featured on Breakfast News and on radio.

Alpha was a ‘way to explore Christianity in an unthreatening way.’ What on earth does this mean? It means that people can hear what passes itself off as the Gospel, without going anywhere near a church. Fine – but it also means not presenting the genuine article. In any genuine church, a man can ask questions freely. No need to go to a free supper. The supper is not a bad idea, though. In our own small church we finish every study with a tea and continue to chat about issues raised, or general topics. But, we do not tell people to “come to Manselton church to explore Christianity”. Nor do we attribute salvation to our teaching. Our teaching is from God’s word, not ourselves. That’s the difference.

The news item quoted a few who say Alpha is ‘branding’ Christianity, and that many who attend their course later drift away again. I expect this to happen, because attendance at a course does not make anyone a Christian. Some will stick around churches only because it seems better than clubbing or living a life of promiscuity (even though many suppers are accompanied by bands).

The report said that the archbishop had referred to the unsaved as the ‘uncommitted’. That one word tells us something big – that he thinks the only real difference between Christians and non-Christians, is that some are ‘committed’ to a church. This is unscriptural, for only a born-again person can be ‘committed’ to God.

The archbishop spoke of the ‘church’ taking risks and going away from the ‘old styles’. That is, giving ‘seekers’ what they want in a way they find comfortable. This is a far cry from the truth and from the presentation of the Gospel, which is through preaching. Suppers are fine. Chatting generally about life is fine. But, God determines that the Gospel – the word that saves – is presented via preaching.

Nicky Gumbel was quoted as saying that Alpha would “transform the Church.” This is ample proof of his view of his own course - it is Alpha that will build the Church, not Christ! Remember that this is consistent with charismatic ideology, which believes that Christ needs a bit of help to usher in His kingdom. We must do this and that, and then He will come again. That is found in Alpha. 

I Think…

Mike Pilavachi, of Soul Survivor, said “I think the thing that the Lord is saying to all of us is…” Mark that man, for he knows nothing of what God is saying! He has no clear mandate and no true calling. He was speaking at a large Alpha supper in London in September, to launch the annual drive to get people interested. A man called  Pastor Agu Irukwu, was similarly unsure…”I am silly enough to believe that in my lifetime I will see revival in London.”

Sadly, his words are true for the first half – he is silly enough to believe it. We are heading for the last days, when there will be no genuine revival, only mass apostasy…and Alpha is already a part of that movement. I am deriding the man, but he, along with all who support Alpha, is deluded. He thinks the spiritual climate is changing. About this he is right, but not for the proper reasons. The spiritual climate began to change rapidly in the mid-1990’s when the vile Toronto Blessing – headed by Sandy Millar and Nicky Gumbel of Alpha! – struck the UK with the force of a tsunami, with the same kind of deathly results. Thousands of churches throughout the UK fell to its Satanic lies and have continued to die. Many churches that did not fall immediately, will certainly fall when the next huge wave strikes, very soon. It is this change that the pastor is feeling, not a change brought by God.

It is weird – Alpha people say that it is only a course, but they load it with all the trappings of a mighty move of God, that preaches the Gospel of Jesus Christ. In reality, it is a dupe, spreading the false gospel of Arminius.

Reading a report of the prayers offered by the team at this event, I am left uncomfortable. They do not make me feel the warmth of God, but the chill wind of deception. They all spoke of transformation, but not in the proper order. People spoke of the way God changed their lives, but it all sounded more like a sales’ pitch for a superior product.

Buy Jesus and He will change your life! For folk with problems and who have messed up their lives, this is wonderful…but where is repentance, talk of being eternally separated from God because of sin, and the reality of Christ’s sacrifice on the cross? None of this seems to be present.

Alpha presents a God Who ‘changes lives’. Alpha’s latest book is about this – ‘The God Who Changes Lives’. It contains testimonies of people whose lives have been changed by attending an Alpha course…they are free from drugs, misery, you name it and they have been freed from it. Don’t get me wrong – it is always wonderful when people turn their lives around. It is just that Alpha makes out that God is only there to give benefits, a great ‘choice’.

The Gospel is not about us getting this or that from God if we choose Him. It’s about God sending us to hell if we are not saved, but that He sent His Son Jesus Christ to die on the cross for us. And those whom He has already chosen will be saved by the same Saviour. It’s nothing to do with what we get in return for choosing Christ – it’s about obedience to Almighty God, whether or not He gives us anything. We must bow the knee, regardless of what we receive! Can you see what I am getting at?

Alpha, then, makes me shiver as a new ice-age covers this land, with the puerile warmth of an Alpha supper. A warmth that is a delusion.

Telegraph Call

In August, The Daily Telegraph called upon the churches to ‘work harder to attract worshippers’. It paid tribute to Alpha, praising its formula of suppers with chat, and saying that it has ‘worked wonders’.

Scripture says something else about this kind of praise, for when the world praises the Church there must be something wrong.

We need not ‘work harder’ to attract people. It is not about how hard we work, but about how true we are to God. When we obey God and live out godly lives, people take notice. In Alpha, people are getting a load of glitter but no substance.

Many church leaders think Alpha is the key to church growth. After all, that is what Alpha itself is claiming! But this is untrue. Church growth is nothing to do with growth in numbers, but in obedience to God. Any numbers are added by God, not by Alpha, or any other human agency.

Even so, I would remind readers that the number of Christians at any one time is always a ‘remnant’…which carries with it the meaning of a ‘remnant of a remnant’. In any age there will be relatively few Christians.

Since the Toronto Blessing ruined so many churches, many true Christians left their local churches and began to meet together in very small numbers in their own homes. These are the true remnant, those who obey. They are the true growth.

Finding God?

An actor was researching Christianity for his role in a film. He attended an Alpha course and found the company stimulating, but he said he could not act as they did (reading the Bible and singing). His conclusion? “After the Alpha course – yea, I felt more that he was there.” (‘He’ meaning God).

That sounds truly inspiring doesn’t it? (!!) No mention of being saved, but, yea, God is somewhere out there. And that was found to be good enough to publish in Alpha News!

Sandy Millar

Vicar of the unHoly Trinity church, Brompton, is to retire in July 2005. His place will be taken by Nicky Gumbel. Sandy Millar is the man who helped to kick-off the TB in the UK, by barking like a dog and crawling about the floor in a stupor. Such is the man who led a ‘movement of God’!

Anyone worth his salt as a Christian recognises what happened to Millar as being of Satanic origin, but the world took it to be from God!!

Gumbel says of him: “under Sandy’s leadership (the church has been) on the cutting edge of change”. And he is spot-on, for since Millar and Gumbel introduced the UK to the TB, the cutting edge has lacerated the churches to pieces, leaving them bleeding and lifeless, with only demonic chatter and music to keep it going.

Finally

Alpha News is full of Alpha, not God. God is just an adjunct to a good supper! Alpha is all about courses, conferences, ‘Alpha advisers’, delegates, students… but no preachers, evangelists, or unsaved souls needing salvation. Yes, Alpha speaks of Jesus, and more or less about a sort-of ‘salvation’, but these are secondary to a supper and a chat!

Anyone who wants to put on an Alpha course must attend training sessions. The reason is that Alpha is a brand, and must be taught uniformly. Does this not smack of a cult, not of God? When God calls a man to ministry He equips that man personally with his own gifts and calling. Such a minister does not need training or special conferences.

This is the Biblical pattern, and this is why I strongly say that leaders of Alpha are uncalled and untaught by God. In modern terms, they are ‘spiritual wannabes’. Like a certain governor in the New Testament who was ‘almost but not quite’ a Christian, they are almost, but not quite, ministers. And the ‘not quite’ makes them not ministers at all.

All ministers of Arminianism are spiritual frauds who should never enter a pulpit. But, they tickle the ears of their hearers, so they stay. That is how our spirit as a nation is almost dead!

--oOo---

Bible Theology Ministries

© December 2004

PO Box 415, SWANSEA  SA5 8YH

Wales

United Kingdom

Make a Donation to support the work of Bible Theology Ministries

info@christiandoctrine.net

www.christiandoctrine.net

 

Search Site

 

Make a
Donation

 

Tell a Friend
about this
Page

 

LATEST!
Outlines
Articles
& other
Documents

 

Search Now:
Amazon Logo
   
     

Last Modified
26 October, 2008

© copyright 2001
Bible Theology Ministries