Christian Doctrine logo, Home


B

i

b

l

e

 

T

h

e

o

l

o

g

y

 

M

i

n

i

s

t

r

i

e

s

A

R

T

I

C

L

E

S




Home

About BTM

The Beacon

eBooks

Contact

Make a
Donation

FAQ

Index of
Topics

Muslim Forum

News

Periodicals

Seeking God

Testimonies

Spiritual Gifts

Part 1

By: K. B. Napier

There are two major theological theories concerning spiritual gifts.  One states that they all disappeared with the last Apostle.  The other claims that the gifts still exist, but that they re-appeared this century, along with the charismatic movement (beginning with the inception of the Pentecostal denomination).  There are other theories in between these extremes.  Neither of the major theories is correct, if we are to follow scripture.

Another very popular theory, as espoused by charismatics (and even by most Calvinists) is that the 'gifts' are those listed in Corinthians.  We discover that scripture knows no such bounds! The 'gifts' have a much wider and more expansive meaning in scripture than men allow.

Rather than argue against theories, in this Article we will instead examine what scripture tells us about spiritual gifts.  Anything that does not base itself on this is to be considered unscriptural (because that is what scripture tells us).  In this context, the term 'unscriptural' is properly used.  Note that there is a difference between what is 'unscriptural' and what is ‘not found in scripture'.  Usually, Christians mean the latter when, in fact, they use the former, and vice versa!  What is the difference?  The difference is a big one:

Unscriptural. This refers to anything that opposes what scripture says.  For example, if a man claims that, say, God created everything in six months, then that would be unscriptural, for it is in opposition to what God's word actually says.  Another example is, say, that 'Jesus is not God'.  This is another statement that is opposed to declared text.  Thus, for something to be 'unscriptural' it must speak against God's word, as it is presented to us in scripture.

Not found in scripture.  On the other hand, the mere fact that something is not found in scripture does not, in itself, make it invalid, or make it 'unscriptural'. Its validity (or not) may depend on other, supporting factors.  For example, we cannot claim that a man wearing a hat is itself 'unscriptural', because there is nothing in scripture about the general use of an head covering for men. Quite simply, it is 'not found in scripture' and, as such, makes no difference to faith or to practice; nor does it oppose scripture. But, if we say that 'men may wear hats in church', then this is 'unscriptural', because for a man to wear a hat in church is to refute God's glory!  Our judgement must depend on context and use.  Many of our church traditions can be listed as 'not found in scripture' (and so to insist on adherence to them as a condition of Christianity is 'unscriptural').

Unfortunately, some become too zealous and claim that certain practices or traditions are 'unscriptural' when, in fact, they are just 'not found in scripture', which is a totally different thing.  Something 'not found in scripture' may, or may not, be 'unscriptural'.  If it is NOT 'unscriptural' then we have no right to invoke Biblical authority, because we have none!  We will, rather, have to 'agree to differ'.  On the other hand, we cannot 'agree to differ' if something really is 'unscriptural', for we have no authority to dispose of scripture, or to amend it.  

We do, though, have authority to demand obedience to what scripture really says.  Not obedience to us, or to our sense of propriety, or to supposed pastoral authority - but obedience to God.  There comes a point when Christians must either stand apart from their fellows, or cast them from fellowship, if what is 'unscriptural' is of a very serious nature.  But, we have no warrant to disfellowship someone merely because something is not found in scripture.  If we insisted on compliance, it would be an human and not a Godly requirement.  It would therefore be an invalid command, devoid of Biblical authority.  

In charismatic 'churches' there is much by way of invalid demands and unwarranted human authority.  It is important that the reader understands what the above section is saying.  We shall see its application later.  Firstly, we should realise that 'gift' or 'gifts' can have a wide range of interpretations, and we should be cautious when listening to, or teaching, what God says about them.  (Indeed, those who do not know the differences plainly show that they have no right or authority to teach them anyway!).  Not understanding this can have far-reaching and even disastrous results.

 The Woman of Samaria

In John 4:10 we have the words of Jesus to the woman of Samaria, at the well:

"Jesus answered and said unto her, If thou knewest the gift of God and who it is that saith to thee, Give me to drink; thou wouldest have asked of him, and he would have given thee living water."

The word 'gift' - dorea - means 'a gift' or 'a present'.  It is from the word doron, meaning a present, or a sacrifice offered to God.  Thus the gift of God is Jesus Christ Himself, as shown in salvation. This interpretation of 'gift of God' is repeated throughout the New Testament in various ways.  The 'living water' or 'water living', is 'true life'. 'Living' is zao, meaning to have true life, blessed and endless in the kingdom of God.  'Water' - hudor - refers to water as the primary element.  'Living water' has vital power in itself and exerts that power over the soul; it is therefore efficacious. 

We can see from this that the 'gift of God' is Christ Himself, Who has power in Himself.  The importance for charismatic theology is that it clearly shows that a 'gift' of God has its source and power in God and NOT in the Christian.  The importance to Calvinism, which generally rejects the idea of gifts being with us today, is that salvation is itself a 'gift' - so how can we reject the gifts?

 Acts 2:38

 "Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost."

 This carries the same meaning as the 'gift of God' in John 4:10 - living waters; salvation.   Exactly the same meaning is given in Acts 8:20.  In Acts 10:45, the Jews were 'astonished' because "on the Gentiles also was poured out the gift of the Holy Ghost".  Note the allusion to water - the same as is found in the above texts and a reference to salvation.  The same is found in Acts 11:27.  In Romans 1:11, though, the meaning for 'gifts' is broadened immensely.

 Romans 1:11

 "...I long to see you, that I may impart unto you some spiritual gift, to the end ye may be established."

'Spiritual gift' now takes on a different meaning, for 'spiritual' - pneumatikos - is 'belonging to the Holy Ghost'; filled and governed by the Spirit of God.  The word 'gift' is charisma, meaning a free gift.  It is a favour received without any merit whatsoever on the part of the receiver; it can also mean and include salvation, which is given in consideration of Christ's merits; grace or gifts that denote extraordinary powers; gifts, given by the Holy Spirit, that distinguish certain Christians that they may serve the Church.  It can also mean the gifts of faith, knowledge, holiness, virtue.

The word charisma is rooted in charizomai, meaning to do a favour or something pleasant to someone; to be gracious and benevolent; to grant forgiveness, to pardon; to preserve from evil. And it does not end there...

The word charizomai is itself the middle voice from charis, meaning that which leads to joy, pleasure, delight, sweetness, charm, grace of speech, loveliness (note that these are also 'fruit'); loving kindness of God which turns people to Christ and then strengthens and keeps them in faith, knowledge, love and Christian virtues.  The effects of all this are found in the root of charis, chairo, meaning to rejoice greatly and to thrive.

Now, which meaning is pertinent to this particular text?  I would suggest that all of them are.  Paul is saying that he wants to give them 'some' spiritual gift.  They are saved by Grace and so already have one of the gifts (salvation).  Now he wants them to 'be established' and to have other gifts. That is, he wants them to be fixed and firm in their beliefs.  Each will have a gift or gifts that are apt for their individual lives, as determined by the Lord.  The meaning of 'established' gives us the interpretation of 'gifts'.  It is sterizo, meaning to make stable, to keep the face turned, to strengthen, to make constant.  So, whatever leads to that objective will be the gift or gifts Paul refers to.

Romans 5:15

In this text the same word – ‘gift’ - is used twice in the translation, but in the original Greek two different words are used.

"But not as the offence, so also (is) the free gift (charisma). For if through the offence of one many be dead, much more the grace of God, and the gift (dorea) by grace, (which is) by one man, Jesus Christ, hath abounded unto many."

Thus, the charisma (favour received by Christ's merits - that is, salvation) is of great efficacy, for it is the dorea, or sacrifice offered by God.  Whatever is given by God must, by definition, be efficacious.

Romans 5:16

In the very next verse, two different Greek words are again translated as 'gift'.  This time the words are dorema and charisma, in that order. The word dorema means a bounty (blessing) or benefaction.  That is, something to the receiver's advantage or benefit.  The root of dorema is doron, meaning a sacrifice offered to God.  Thus every spiritual gift is linked, inextricably, to the 'gift of God', Who is Jesus Christ Himself - the One Who alone can save us; the greatest and most fundamental Gift of all, without Whom there can be no other gifts.

This is shown to us by Romans 6:23, which spells out what is meant:

"...the wages of sin (is) death; but the gift (charisma - pardon/eternal salvation) of God (is) eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord." 

1 Corinthians 13:2

"And though I have (the gift of) prophecy..."

Note that the word 'gift' is implied in this text, by the presence of the spiritual ability to prophesy and, in this case, means 'the benefit of prophecy', or 'the spiritual blessing of prophecy'.  The text itself provides such an interpretation.  What we are seeing is that the charismatic use of the term 'gift' or 'gifts' is wholesale.  That is, it is used in virtually the same way in every text containing the word!  As we can see, each text must be treated on its own when it comes to interpretation, or we lose what can be a very subtle change in meaning - but sometimes the meaning is different, not simply subtle.  

Note that 'fruit' can also be a 'gift' - love, for example, is called a 'gift', but a 'fruit' in other texts.  This should not surprise us, for the fruit are merely the effects of living in Christ.  That is, the effect of living in Christ is to use the gifts given to us by the Holy Spirit.  The gift of 'love' will show itself as love. Thus, the cause will also be the effect...the presence of love within a man will show itself in loving actions and character, and the more it is shown, the greater will be the effects of love and the more it will be noticed!

The gifts (benefits) and the fruit are, then, intertwined and are not separate. This means that we cannot separate the phenomena experienced by charismatics in the Toronto Blessing (or in any other display of a supposed 'movement of the Holy Spirit') from the claimed 'fruit'!  (See Article A-00035, 'Fruit of the Spirit').  Later we shall also see that 'gifts' refer to everything good that comes from God.

2 Corinthians 9:15

What is the "unspeakable gift" in this text?  'Unspeakable' is 'indescribable' or 'words fail'.  The gift - dorea - is the free gift obtained by a sacrifice to God, salvation.

Ephesians 2:8

The "gift of God" in this text is doron, meaning 'a present' (and therefore free - not even dependent upon faith).  The "gift of the grace of God" in Ephesians 3:7 is exactly the same, i.e. Paul was made a 'minister' by the free pleasure of God.

Ephesians 4:7

Here we come across an interesting fact - a Biblically-declared fact that destroys the charismatic notion that we can claim this or that spiritual benefit simply by asking for it.  The text tells us that the degree of Christian virtue we have depends on the portion Christ has given us.  Whatever is our portion, is His dorea or gift - a present.  A present is something given to us freely and it cannot be earned or requested.  Thus we cannot have 'more of Him'.  Rather, He gives us whatever He knows is fit for our lives.  He measures it out precisely, as He has predetermined before time began.

Philippians 4:17

"Not because I desire a gift, but I desire fruit that may abound to your account.

The 'gift' is doma, meaning something bestowed to one's advantage, or 'necessary things'.  It is based on didomi - wages or reward - and this is the interpretation in this text.  Paul is saying that he does not want a reward, he only wants the people to have fruit in abundance.  The fruit - karpos - refer to the effects of being saved.  Thus, Paul wishes only that the Christians he is writing to should express their beliefs in a true fashion, that they may be acceptable to the Lord.

1 Timothy 4:14

This text speaks of a gift given by the 'laying on of hands' (of the elders).  The 'laying on' or epthesis was a sacred rite stemming from Jewish worship.  It was used when praying for, or when conferring divine blessings upon, another...especially bodily health or the Holy Spirit, e.g. at baptism or when inaugurated to office (teacher, pastor, etc.).

Does this mean that the Holy Spirit is given by the laying on of hands?  No, it cannot, for the Holy Spirit is received at salvation.  So, this text cannot refer to the giving of a blessing. The root of epithesis is epitithemi, meaning to 'bid to be laid on' (rather than 'passing on' or 'giving'). That is, it is a request for something.  Epitithemi is itself based on tithemi, which includes the meaning of laying-aside (e.g. for service), or to establish/ordain. The word 'hands', cheir, when used figuratively of God, refers to the symbol of His power.

We can thus see that the laying on of hands does not transmit power from one human to another - it symbolises the giving of God's power.  The importance of this is obvious when we consider the claims made by charismatics.  Any power a Christian has is not his own.  It is owned and controlled by God.  The Christian is merely a conduit, not the provider, of power.  Thus, he cannot pass-on that power or any gift.  When he lays hands upon another person, the gift or power is given by God, not by him.  The use of the hands simply symbolises that God has given the power.  

In many instances, there are reports of tingling or heat.  This can be either God acting upon the person directly, or Satan.  Satanic laying-on of hands is often accompanied by these sensations.  Hence the need to be cautious and to know the difference.  There is a self-glory and sense of mockery in the laying-on of hands amongst charismatics today.  Witness the 'experiments' in varying ways to 'transmit' the 'power' from one person to another!  Like the young girl who jabbed her finger at the heads of a row of adults, who all fell down under the 'Spirit'!  Or the leader who blew across the room at a row of people, who all fell down!  Or the folk who are violently thrust backwards when a hand is placed in front of their heads, but not touching them!  This all comes from the charismatic belief that the Holy Spirit is 'transmitted' by human hands. There are many more examples of this charismatic arrogance.

There is something at once naive and yet outrageous in all this, that human beings should believe they have the power within themselves to 'give God' to others with their own hands, as though He were a commodity at their command.  There is no essential difference between this and the blasphemy of  Romanist priests in the mass!

Hebrews 6:4

"...tasted of the heavenly gift (dorea) and were made partakers of the Holy Ghost."

This refers to those who are saved, the 'gift' being God's pardon as given in personal salvation.  It is an 'heavenly' gift or epouranios, meaning of heavenly origin and nature.  Epouranios is rooted in ouranos, meaning where God dwells.  Thus, a gift cannot originate with, or be contained by, a man;  it can only come direct from God.  Man is only the 'conduit' through which God acts - he is not the container or originator of a blessing.  This is repeated in the next example.

James 1:17

"Every good gift and every perfect gift is from above, and cometh from the Father of lights..."

Only good comes from God and all evil gifts come from Satan (father of darkness), as the sense of the text implies.  The gift in verse 17 is dosis - a giving - which is from the base of didomi.  That is, everything to our advantage is from God, Who is the 'Father of lights' or 'Father of the lights'.  The 'Father' is pater or Creator of the light, or phos, which is purity, brilliance; truth and its knowledge and the spiritual purity that comes from it; made manifest.  In this we see the fullest meaning of what a gift really is - it is anything spiritually good that arises from the measure of purity and truth given to each Believer by God.

By comparison the charismatic claims are childish nonsense. As we have already suggested, the  full meaning of spiritual gifts is expansive.  Indeed, it is as expansive as God's character.  The charismatic meaning, however, is limited, tainted and greatly oversimplified.

There are other meanings for 'gift' in the New Testament, some of which correspond with Old Testament meanings.  For example:

Matthew 2:11

"...they presented unto him gifts; gold, and frankincense, and myrrh."

The 'gifts' - doron - refer to gifts offered as an expression of honour.  It is also likely that the magi lay prostrate on their faces, or at the very least bowed on their knees, touching the ground with their foreheads.  All of this was normal when subjects visited a greater prince or king and was an expression of honour and subjection.  A lesser meaning for gift - doma - is spoken of in Matthew 7:11.  Here it means a simple present, or something that was necessary.  This meaning is used extensively in the Old Testament.

Luke 21:5

The temple was "adorned with goodly stones and gifts...".  Yet another word is used for 'gifts' - anathema.  Used in a good sense, it means a 'present' consecrated and put in a temple.  It can also mean an offering resulting from a vow.

Romans 11:29

The gifts of God are given "without repentance"; He does not regret giving them.  Some Believers, trying to come to terms with the falsity of the current charismatic phenomena, say that God gave true gifts to charismatics, but they are now abusing them.  This is not possible, if we recognise what gifts are and Who controls them.  We can sum the position up as follows:

1.

God gives us gifts as and when He wishes.

2.

We cannot 'claim' random gifts, nor may we demand 'more'.

3.

God gives us gifts and blessings in measure.  That is, as much or as little as He wishes.  This underlines the fact that He is in control.

4.

God cannot make mistakes - hence He does not regret giving us anything.

5.

Because He does not make mistakes, we cannot abuse or misuse His gifts. This is because God controls the gifts - what he gives and the way that we use them.  When a gift is to be used, it is for a particular purpose.  Thus, its use is always effective and cannot give a wrong or no result.  Compare this with charismatic 'gifts' which often 'fail'!

6.

A gift that 'fails' is not a true gift at all. Or, a man with a true gift is attempting to use it without being first prompted to do so by God.  Thus the delusion of the gift fails, NOT the actual gift.  We 'fail' when we try to do something outside of God's prompting.  Thus, the evidence against charismatic claims is devastating in its judgement.

7.

Furthermore, the power we have is also under God's direct command.  We may not use it as we wish.  It is easy to see how Satan can make us think we are displaying the true spiritual power of God - he gives us a poor substitute which we accept, because of our zeal to have it.  This is what is happening in current charismatic circles.  Sadly, however, the zeal for 'power' is not matched by a corresponding zeal for personal purity and knowledge, etc.

 Romans 12:6

Again, the text supports the fact that God gives us gifts in measure (and not according to what we demand).  Also, the type of gift differs, depending on what God wishes to appoint to us:

"Having then gifts differing according to the grace that is given to us...according to the proportion of faith."

It may be argued (as it often is by charismatics) that what we have depends on the level of our faith.  No, it is God Who determines the level of our faith!  And it is God Who determines what gifts we shall have and when we are to use them.  Thus "according to the proportion of faith" means 'according to the faith God has given to us'.

Note, in 1 Corinthians 12:1, Paul says "Now concerning spiritual (gifts)."  The word 'gifts' is not included in the original Greek, but is implied.  We must not portray the old English translation in a modern way.  The correct interpretation is thus "Now concerning spiritual things (pneumatikos), or 'spiritual matters' ".  See how very broad the meaning really is?  The charismatic use is self-limiting and almost derogatory.  Paul is speaking about all (good) spiritual things, not just those few sample 'gifts' he mentions in his letters and which he begins to list in verse two of this chapter.

It is possible to list the fruit amongst the gifts, too, for they are also 'spiritual things'. Such a possibility is heightened when we consider, say, the gift of  love, or knowledge, etc., which are also listed elsewhere as examples of fruit!  This intricate intertwining of truths serves to remind us that God's word is far bigger than we think it is, its scope and breadth being too immense for us to encapsulate it fully within human theories.  (It is a truism that the more we learn of God the less we appear to know!).

Charismatic theories are speculation based on speculation.  They separate and divide God's word to suit preferred meanings.  If we apply all of the above to such false charismatic movements as the Toronto Blessing, we can see the magnitude of the error.

We will now concentrate on the gifts as particularly portrayed in Corinthians.

GOD'S POWER IN BELIEVERS

The book of Corinthians is the 'happy hunting ground' of charismatics.  Let us, then, see what it says about the gifts.  It will become clear that charismatics have missed the mark.  Equally, so have others, whose theology is certainly closer to the Truth, but whose prejudice against the gifts prevents them from understanding what God's word actually says.

The difference between the two extremes is that with charismatics (those who are saved, that is), the danger is that they are easy prey to Satanic attack and oppression; with others, they are unaware of the fullness of God and of the marvellous workings of the Holy Spirit and so they never attain a significant level of spiritual life.  In these, Satan suppresses joy and understanding.

There is a saying that 'knowledge is power'.  That is true, almost literally, when it comes to what is being discussed in this Article, for the Lord urges us to gain knowledge, which is closely connected with the experience of His power (I will not take this loose analogy too far).  

Paul makes an urgent plea, that he should see the power in his fellow Believers, because power must be the foundation of our lives. Spiritual power is not the prerogative of charismatics!  It should be the normal experience of all Believers at all times.  What does the Apostle mean by the 'power'?  (Calvinists and others will not like what he says, but they must not distort scripture to fit their views). (Also see Article 'Power', A-00079)

1 Corinthians 4: 19,20

"But I will come to you shortly, if the Lord will, and will know, not the speech of them which are puffed up, but the power.

For the kingdom of God (is) not in word, but in power."

Before we look at the power, note that the 'kingdom of God' is not some future event or place.  It is a present state of soul.  Kingdom is basileia. Generally, this word does not refer to a physical kingdom, but to the rule by a prince or king.  In the New Testament, it means the rule of the Messiah in our hearts and lives.  As this begins the moment we are saved, it obviously means that the 'kingdom of God' is with us now, and is present in every Believer.  

That the kingdom refers to the ruler and not to a land or physical kingdom is discovered in the root of basileia, basileus, meaning prince, commander, king.  These definitions refute the classical dispensationalist idea of an actual millennium on this earth.

To get back to power...

The word 'speech' is logos - one of those Greek words that is familiar to virtually every Believer.  However, most Believers only know one interpretation of logos - 'word'.  There is much more to logos than 'word'.  It can also mean ideas and concepts; what God says; doctrine; dispute; used by the mind only; a reference to salvation, and so on. Rooted in lego, is also means: to say, to teach, exhort, advise, command.  The context tells us that logo is what men say (whether doctrine, dispute, or anything else concerning their beliefs).

To be 'puffed up' - phusioo - is to be inflated, swollen up, made proud, to bear oneself loftily. Or, to put it in common language - a 'big-head'!

The word 'power' is dunamis.  It means mighty work; power in a thing because of its nature; power for performing miracles; moral power and excellence of soul.  From dunamai, it means to be capable, strong and powerful. 'Word' in verse 20 is the same as 'speech' in verse 19.

Thus, these two verses are incapable of being misinterpreted because the text itself provides us with the meaning.  Paul is saying that he does not want to hear the mere words of proud men; he wants to see the evidence of their salvation (or 'fruit').  The evidence must be forthcoming, for salvation confers spiritual power upon a person.  The only thing that prevents us from showing that power in our lives is our sinfulness and refusal to allow the power of God to operate.

We can see that the power can refer to working of miracles.  Some Believers work miracles. We cannot and must not deny this.  Paul does NOT tell us this facility is only for Apostolic times. The context and meaning is one that applies to all Believers at all times, there being no indication to the contrary.  But the major meaning is that of moral virtue and strength of spiritual character. To concentrate too much on miracles is to miss the point.  The power to be like this is inherent in salvation, because of its nature. 

Salvation is supernatural and brings with it supernatural power.  Otherwise it is like a 'blip' on a radar screen, which comes and goes suddenly, never to be seen again.  After all, we have a God Who is God Almighty, supernatural, the same yesterday, today and forever.  His promises have been given and He never regrets them.  Therefore we can expect to receive the same blessings as were given to earlier Believers...otherwise we are left with the shell of a former deity, Whose power is no more.  This, however, is not the case and so we, too, receive power from the Lord.

When we are saved we become 'new creatures' and already have one foot in heaven, the place where God is.  Our spirits are now alive and commune with the Holy Spirit.  We can only do this by being supernaturally empowered to do so.  We are empowered (re dunamai) to be 'capable, strong and powerful' in our new Christian lives.  There is a sadness about Christians who believe that this power is only available to some; they bemoan the fact that they themselves are so weak and lacking in spiritual excitement.  The reason for their weak state is not God, but themselves!  Their refusal to act according to God's will and their insistence on continuing in their sins, prevents them from being what they ought to be....full of spiritual power.

Those (Christians) who attend charismatic meetings, especially the more recent 'Toronto Blessing' meetings, attend because of acute awareness of their lack (but with an underlying rejection of gaining true knowledge - they want an instant answer).  They see and hear 'power' in others in these meetings and so they want to 'have some' for themselves.  It is a sign of desperation, or of resignation to their futility.  Either way, their poor spiritual state causes them to ignore Biblical warnings and teaching, and to be misled by Satan's power.

They do not understand that Satan has power, too, even though they agree to the fact in their heads.  He has great power and he is using it currently to fool and seduce even Christians, as the next text indicates.  (Others who attend are either unbelievers who pretend to be Believers, or Believers with carnal intentions - they want the power and the 'blessing' but not the spiritual growth, maturity and commitment).

The 'power' of Christians, then, is of God and from God, but it is not inherently of the Believer. Whilst the Believer may display power in all kinds of ways, that power is not indwelling in the sense that it is his alone.  The Believer is only the 'conduit', through whom the Holy Spirit acts.  The alternative is that the Believer owns and contains the power and dispenses with it at any time he pleases - which is a Romanist/cultist/occultist concept.

The power given to Believers is behind all that they (should) do, and it is behind gifts and fruit of the Spirit.  Now we shall take a closer look at the gifts, beginning with Luke 11:13, a text that has been much misused:

Luke 11:13

"If ye then, being evil, know how to give good gifts unto your children: how much more shall (your) heavenly Father give to them that ask him?"

Charismatics assume that they may ask God for whatever they wish, especially the gifts, and He will automatically give them.  The text, however, does not say that; nor does the rest of scripture.  God does not contradict Himself.  What, then, does this verse tell us?  Its context is this: a man went late at night to his friend - he needed food because visitors had come unexpectedly.  The true friend will, of course, get up and give the food.  Then we are told that a father does not give his son a stone when he wants bread.  Now, in this text, we are shown that although we are sinful people, we nevertheless love and help our children.  We give them 'gifts' when they ask for them.  It is important to understand what is meant by 'gifts' and 'ask'  in this context.

The 'gifts' are qualified and defined for us in the preceding text - they are those things that are spiritually necessary (although at other times they can be physical, emotional, or intellectual). This may, or may not, include the 'gifts' spoken of in Corinthians.  Remember that 'spiritual gifts' actually means 'spiritual things'.  The gifts in this text are given when we ask for them.  Bear in mind that God only answers those prayers that he Himself has prompted us to offer back to Him.  This is why, if we do not "ask aright" we experience the 'stone wall' of silence.  Thus, we may only ask "according to the portion" given to us by God.  Outside of this proviso there are no answers!

The text is telling us, then, to ask God for whatever we need (necessities), and He will give them to us.  The necessities are also defined for us in the words "Holy Spirit" - they are spiritual things needed for us to continue our daily walk with God.  It logically follows that God will only give us what we need, as already allotted by Himself, and which have been predetermined for the particular Christian activities we are to perform on His behalf.  

As God is not reactionary and cannot act randomly, we cannot request something that He has not already determined for us. Or, rather, we can request it - but we will not get it!  This means that the charismatic claims are false, whether by deliberation or by delusion.  We cannot simply demand, or even request, gifts that God has not already provided for us in eternity. God will give us whatever He wishes at whatever time.  Yet, charismatics call people to the front, where they automatically dispense salvation and the Holy Spirit, evidenced in so-called 'tongues'.  They also dispense gifts - even calling on God to provide certain types of gifts!  None of this is scriptural or possible, as we can see from the above.  With all this in mind, let us now consider more Corinthian texts...

SPIRITUAL  THINGS

Once we realise that 'spiritual gifts' means 'spiritual things', we can understand that the list of gifts given in Corinthians is a sample list only.  The gifts range from love and salvation to the more spectacular miracles.

1 Corinthians 12:4

"Now there are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit." 

Diversities - diairesis - are different gifts distributed to different people.  That is, distributed by (God's) choice (haireomai).  This reinforces what has already been said.  Gifts - charisma - favour given without merit on the part of the receiver; pardon and salvation given on the merits of Jesus Christ.  Also, grace or gifts denoting extraordinary powers, due to the power of the divine grace operating on the souls of the recipient and user, by the Holy Spirit.  So, we see that the gifts are not our own, but are displayed through us by the Holy Spirit.

Everyone receives a gift or gifts pertinent to the portion determined by the Lord, Who also determines the measure of the gifts and when they are to be used.  All (good) gifts are given by the same Holy Spirit, so there is an unity amongst them.

Note that the charisma 'denote' extraordinary powers and that those powers are due to the power of divine grace (favour).  'Denoted' means 'symbolised'.  Thus,  the gifts are only symbols of God's power - they are not signs of actual power within ourselves.  To put it another way, the power of the gifts and what they do, come direct from the Holy Spirit.  As has already been said, the power is not contained within ourselves, but is 'passed through' us as though we were conduits.

At this juncture, then, it is wise to repeat an earlier statement - that charismatics who claim to be able to use their 'gifts' at any time for any purpose are deluded, according to the Biblical evidence and to the logic of scriptural theology.  These facts lead us to disturbing conclusions concerning charismatic gifts and their use.  For example:

 

1.

The 'gifts' claimed by most charismatics cannot be genuine.

2.

The claim, that the gifts are used at the wish of the gift-user, is false.

3.

Many charismatics are opposing the Lord by pretending to use spiritual power, when the Lord has not prompted them to do so.

4.

Their claim to any-time use, and ownership of, the gifts is heretical or occultist, or both, and is basically Arminian.

There are other conclusions, but the above are suffice to demonstrate the potential dangers in charismatic-style thinking, which is unscriptural.

1 Corinthians 12:7

"...but the manifestation of the Spirit is given to every man to profit withal."

'Manifestation', or phanerosis, is rooted in phaneroo, meaning to appear; show; openly declare; make known what has been unknown by word, deed or any other means; to be plainly recognised; make known by teaching (Bible study or teaching is just as much a manifestation as is, say, miracles).  Phanaroo is rooted in phaneros - to spread abroad; plainly recognised.  Based on phaino, it means to bring into the light; to cause to shine, to be bright; to appear to the mind.  Phaino is traced back to its own root of phos - the same word used in the text calling God the "Father of lights".  Metaphorically, 'God is light', i.e. pure, brilliant, etc.  It speaks of truth, knowledge and the spiritual purity that is the result.  It also refers to the power to understand moral and spiritual truth.

What does all this tell us?  We are not littering the page with Greek simply to make it look academic!  God is an economist - He always uses words that mean exactly what He wishes to say. We are told that the gifts are a 'manifestation of the Spirit' and are NOT of ourselves; Gifts are an appearance of power from God that was not previously in existence in our lives;  Such gifts are plain to observe and are obviously gifts (and not just human talents or pretence; the majority of charismatics appear to play-act). They are based on the purity and activity of the Father of lights, in Whom is 'no shade' of turning.

The phenomena experienced and seen in charismatic meetings, by comparison, are dubious and grey!  In many cases, it is painfully obvious that they are fraudulent, either deliberately or by way of a psychological desire for the gifts and the experiences to exist.  That is why charismatics are easy prey for Satan and his demons, who are presently spreading their counterfeit gifts amongst Christian and non-Christian charismatics alike.

Sadly, many think they are true gifts, and so they fall heavily under the influence of the 'Father of lies'.  Another lie is that the gifts - especially that of 'tongues' - is for 'private use'.  Indeed, many Charismatics boast of their private gift!  Yet, the text tells us that the gifts are given to "every man to profit withal" (repeated elsewhere).

'By 'every man' we should understand it to mean 'every man who is saved'.  God's gifts are not universally available.  The word 'profit' - sumphero - means to carry with others; to contribute in order to help; that is, to be profitable.  This is based on sun, a primary preposition denoting union or 'with', and on phero - to be moved inwardly/prompted and to move by bearing, with the idea of urgency. None of this allows us to use gifts 'privately'.  They are for the benefit of everyone - as the qualifying word 'withal' clearly demonstrates.

This being so, and the fact that gifts may only be used when prompted by God (the only time they are effective), it means that gifts used privately are either NOT God's gifts at all, or the person who has the gifts is deluded or is deliberately opposing the Lord, by trying to use them without prompting.  (See Article 'Tongues', which proves that  charismatic tongues are false).

Gifts, then, are for the benefit of all the Church, to be relayed as and when God prompts them to be used.  This also means, for example, that 'ministries of healing' are likely to be false, because the user assumes that he can heal at any time and presumes upon the Lord by advertising such healings in advance.

We now have background information on the gifts.  In Part 2 on the gifts we will examine what scripture really says about them.  It will be made clear that the charismatic interpretation and use of 'gifts' is far removed from what God says in His word.  Obviously, if that is so, then charismatics do not just get it all wrong - they oppose the Lord and misuse His word, which is sin.  (Readers should also read the Article on Charismaticism, which will show that the charismatic ethos is basically heretical and apostate).

Note, too, that the preaching of the word, the gifts, the general walk of Believers, phenomena and fruit of the Spirit, are all interwoven in God's word.  They cannot be separated.  Therefore, the claim by charismatics, that we can easily separate one from the other (i.e. we can ignore what is bad and simply accept the 'fruit') is wrong and unbiblical; it is evidence of a lack of true Biblical and theological perspective in those who claim to be our Brethren. 

As I indicate in the Article 'Charismaticism' the salvation of the majority of charismatics should be seriously doubted - not because I say so, or because I personally disagree with what they say, but because they do not preach the gospel of Jesus Christ.  If this is true, then what they preach is "no gospel" and is false.  This statement will particularly horrify people, but our feelings are not relevant to the issue. Let not any friendships we may have with charismatics divert us from a proper examination of scripture. We must rebuke Christians who are involved in charismaticism and warn the others that they are not saved by a false gospel.

Now please read Article A-00033 Part 2 which continues the topic.

---oOo---

Bible Theology Ministries

© November 1994

PO Box 415, SWANSEA  SA5 8YH

Wales

United Kingdom

Make a Donation to support the work of Bible Theology Ministries

info@christiandoctrine.net

www.christiandoctrine.net

 

Search Site

 

Make a
Donation

 

Tell a Friend
about this
Page

 

LATEST!
Outlines
Articles
& other
Documents

 

Search Now:
Amazon Logo

 

 
     

Last Modified
26 October, 2008

© copyright 2001
Bible Theology Ministries